Graham Bart was an irreplaceable value.
The first time I
had a serious conversation with Graham was right after we had finished taking a
ballet class together. I noticed that he was reading the novel Atlas
Shrugged by Ayn Rand, and I asked him if he liked it. His answer was yes,
but it sounded as though he had many reservations. In the years to follow, these
reservations became fewer and fewer.
A month or so later we were working
on a Spring workshop production of the ballet, Cinderella. This was in
1985. It was our first project together and among other things, we were writing
the synopsis for the program. In my apartment, at my computer terminal, we would
spend hours debating over which was the more accurate way to phrase a particular
sentence. Till this day, whenever I hear the music of Prokofiev's
Cinderella, all I do is think about how much tea we drank, while working
all-night long on the program, before attending our regular jobs the next
morning--only to repeat the process again the next day. One reason we would
spend all night instead of a few hours was because we would constantly get
sidetracked into issues dealing with philosophy. Graham was fascinated with both
the theoretical and practical aspects of philosophy. And I had studied the
subject for some time, so I had many answers to his questions.
By the
time the Cinderalla production went on, Graham was in Brazil with his
fiancee, taking care of more important business. Somehow the production was
still a success. But before he left for Brazil, I gave him copies of the rest of
Ayn Rand's works to read.
Then one evening in the fall I was taking a
ballet class and suddenly appearing in the doorway of the studio was Graham. He
had just gotten off a plane from London and didn't have any place to stay.
Fortunately, my brother Damian had just boarded a plane to London for one week.
I let Graham stay in Damian's place (thanks Damian) while I found him an
apartment in the building next door to mine. This began the most productive
phase of both of our lives.
It started in his new apartment. With
electric saws, drills and other power tools, we built a loft, bookshelves and
other custom furniture. One thing about Graham is that he would never start a
job unless he knew he would finish it. He would not finish a job unless it was
done right. As a result of the work, he was happy with his new living quarters.
A few weeks later I began holding a series of taped lecture courses on
Ayn Rand's philosophy of Objectivism, at my apartment. This gave Graham a chance
to hear the principles of the philosophy from its authorized spokesmen, instead
of only listening to my views. Of course this did not stop him from asking me
countless questions, but I happily welcomed his interest.
I remember one
night after the philosophy class was over, we went back to his apartment to
rearrange the bookshelves. Graham had a large close-up photograph of his
fiancee, Ana Botafogo, prima ballerina of Rio de Janeiro. he told me how much he
had missed her. I remember wishing for the day when I too would have this
feeling for such a special woman in my life.
At this time Graham was
preparing for his career in real estate. His interests varied from sales and
marketing, to development and management. In addition, I was ready to widen my
professional activities beyond that of a computer technician. We spoke at length
about starting a business together in real estate. We had it planned that he
would be in charge of sales and I would be in charge of management. This would
enable us to utilize the skills in which we were best suited. Unfortunately,
growing up on welfare in my youth showed me the importance of having a steady
income, so I decided not to take such a risk. Not yet. But I knew that
eventually we would work together as partners since we were such a complementary
team.
Meanwhile Spring was beginning and with it came the annual ballet
workshop performances. This time it would be Giselle. Of course, along
with Giselle came more all-night discussions with Graham regarding the outline
of the program, the business arrangements-- and philosophy. Fortunately, he was
in New York to see the results of his work as the producer of the show. I
remember right before the performance would begin, Graham would appear from
behind the curtain and announce to the audience the cast for that particular
program. I would stand right behind the curtain, with my costume on, and listen
for any ways to make his speech more dynamic. Graham appreciated constructive
criticism. Especially if it was from someone who knew what he was talking about.
Giselle was a complete success. Everybody loved it, even the media. It
was the first time Graham had seen me dance on stage, and I treasured his
compliments.
At this point I had left my job and began planning my next
career move. A friend of mine told me that Merrill Lynch had opportunities in
the Data Communications department. The hours were 7pm to 7am, three nights a
week. This was very appealing to me as I had grown tired of the 9 to 5 routine.
So I prepared my self by having a mock interview with Graham. The first
interview he gave me was one of the most grueling experiences I ever had. He
exposed gaping holes in my approach to the interview process. I performed much
better in the next two interviews he gave me and I was fully prepared for
Merrill Lynch.
Then came the 4th of July (my favorite holiday) and our
trip to visit my parents on Staten Island. The ferry ride was splendid. We had a
close-up view of the Statue of Liberty -- which was celebrating its 100th
anniversary. Graham was engaged to be married to Ana in Rio on August 1st. I
knew it would be impossible for me to attend the wedding, so I arranged to have
a surprise party for him honoring this event. My mother, father and brother,
Peter, were there. When we brought out the cake and started singing, the
expression on Graham's face was so emotional that I have no words to describe
it. He later sent me a letter in the mail expressing his gratitude. This was the
final seal on our friendship for life. I had never seen him so happy.
My
interview with Merrill Lynch was a thousand times easier than any of the mock
interviews Graham gave me. (Needless to say, I got the job.) A week or so later
I helped Graham move to his new apartment in Greenwich Village. More bookshelves
and cabinets were to be built. Then he was on his way to Rio to get married and
I was on my way to Merrill Lynch with a $10,000 a year increase in income. We
were both extremely happy.
I called him in Rio the day after his wedding
and he was elated yet torn by a dilemma: Ana had just been invited to dance in
Rome but this meant that they would have to shorten their honeymoon. They
decided to accept the offer to go to Rome. From there they both came to New York
to live in their new apartment.
The next few months were crucial to us
all. Graham had some very promising deals surfacing in real estate. Ana was
becoming much more comfortable and happy in New York and I was establishing
myself at Merrill Lynch.
Then came Thanksgiving (my other favorite
holiday) and a visit to my sisters' (P and D) apartment. This was
another success as my family became more delighted with Graham and Ana. We even
videotaped the occasion.
Then it was December, the month in which Graham
and I were born. Ana was dancing in Rio and Graham was working here in New York.
I convinced him to attend a performance of The Nutcracker I was dancing
in upstate New York. Another success. Both of our schedules were very busy by
then and since we didn't live as close to each other as before, we were unable
to be together on his birthday. My birthday followed three days later and I
arranged to have a party at Robin Field's apartment. Robin was one of the first
Objectivists I ever met and we had become very good friends over the years. He
is an excellent composer, lyricist, singer and arranger. The party was wonderful
with the exception of the phonecall I received from Graham. I called to say that
he could not attend. He explained that all three of the real estate deals he had
been working on had fallen through, he had no money and was immediately on his
way to Rio to be with Ana. Of course, I understood his situation and I wished
there was something I could do to help.
On came the New Year and Graham
and Ana were back in New York. As usual, I was happy to see them. A few weeks
later I convinced Ana to take a partnering dance class with me (one of the
highlights of my life). After the class was finished, Graham, Ana and I went out
for a discussion. Graham explained to me that he had no income for the past four
months. This, coupled with the rising cost of living in New York, left him no
choice but to move to Rio de Janeiro. I was stunned. This was the last thing I
expected to hear. But everything he said was a fact and there was nothing I
could do to convince him otherwise. He also explained that he was going to
England to tell his family the news. As it happened, I was scheduled for one
week off from work at Merrill Lynch. So he, Ana and I arranged to go to England
together in the end of January. The next two weeks were pure misery for me. I
spent countless hours depressed over the fact that by best friend would be
moving thousands and thousands of miles away.
Then came London. It was
wonderful. The city is more similar to New York than any other place I've ever
been. The three of us spent the entire morning and afternoon walking around.
Then we boarded the train to visit his parents, who live in the suburbs. Meeting
his parents was a sheer delight. His mother, Margot, was the most gracious
hostess I ever met. His father, Kenneth, was very charming and intelligent. I
then understood why Graham turned out the way he did. We spent most of the
weekend discussing issues in philosophy. (I have to mention that nine-tenths of
the time Graham and I were together we were discussing philosophy and its
application to life.)
His parents accepted his decision to move to Rio.
They had been there for the wedding so they were actually more familiar with Rio
than they were with New York. On back to London to meet more family and discuss
more philosophy. This time it was his sister, Mirella. She too reminded me much
of Graham, in intelligence, courtesy, manners, etc. I regret that I did not also
meet Graham's other sister, Carola, but this will be taken care of in the coming
fall.
My time was up in England and Graham and Ana went back to see his
parents again for a few more days.
Back to New York. One night I called
Robin Field to see how he was doing. He told me he was just about to perform his
newly finished composition, an anonymously written fairy tale, which he had
tightened up philosophically and turned into a comic opera. I called up Graham
and invited him and Ana to come along to hear it. We all fell in love with the
composition. Graham explained to Robin that he could find an audience for this
work in Brazil. Thus began the Crystal Palace project.
The next
week I arranged to have a surprise going-away party for Graham and Ana. I
invited my parents, a few of my brothers and sisters and some of my close
friends. Once again we brought out the cake and the expression on Graham's face
was one of elation multiplied tenfold.
From my point of view, I thought
that Graham would be leaving America for only a few years. I thought this would
give me some time to gain experience in the business world so that when he came
back here, we would excel as business associates in real estate, and other
fields. (We would probably argue over whose name should come first in the
partnership.)
We had spent the next several months in touch by telephone
and mail. I remember the first letter I wrote to Graham since he moved to Rio. I
asked him questions about his new situation and filled him in on my latest
achievements. I closed the letter with a quote from the hero in The
Fountainhead, "You are the one encounter in my life that can never be repeated."
Ayn Rand eloquently summed up my thoughts and feelings about Graham.
The
next time I saw him was in his new home in Rio. It was mid-November, cold in New
York and hot in Rio. Of course it was wonderful to see both Graham and Ana, and
I also wanted to go the beach to see some of the world's most beautiful women in
their "dental floss" bikinis. Unfortunately, the sun did not show its face for
the first three days I was there. Graham and I went swimming anyway. It was at a
military base where there were two sections of water divided by a mountain. One
section was very calm, the other was very turbulent. Of course we went into the
turbulent one. Graham brought a two foot long surfboard and taught me how to
ride the violent waves. I remember just thinking that I had mastered this art
when a huge wave came in and flipped me completely upside down into the sand at
the bottom of the water. Ten seconds later, when I regained my consciousness, I
saw Graham fifteen feet away, laughing hysterically. I could do nothing but
laugh myself.
Much more fun was to come in Rio, as it was a pleasure
meeting Ana's family. They are in the same class as Graham's family, very warm
and charming. Ana's father, Dr. Ernani, did not speak any English but Graham
served as an excellent interpreter for us. And her mother, Maria Dulce, was a
gracious hostess. Her brother, Naninho, and his wife, Marcia, were a marvelous
couple.
Graham and I went to all the usual tourist sites, and I enjoyed
it immensely. It was great to see him in his adopted country. And I couldn't
believe how popular Ana was. Everywhere we went in public, she was recognized
and praised.
Finally I got a chance to go to the Ipanema beach. This was
one of the highlights. My eyes were ready to pop out as I saw one gorgeous woman
after another. I told Graham jokingly that if America ever collapsed, I should
move to Rio and probably die of exhaustion, with a smile on my face. I know he
wished I wasn't joking because he asked me what I would do if I fell in love
with a Brazilian woman. I told him that of course I would bring her to America
to live happily ever after. Graham never knew it, but this actually almost
happened.
While Ana was dancing in other cities outside of Rio, Graham
and I spent one day in Sao Paulo--Brazil's equivalent to New York. I thoroughly
enjoyed it. We met his good friend, a brilliant artist, Francisco Faria. The
three of us went to one of the largest museums in the world to see a modern art
exhibition. More philosophy and more laughs, although Graham and I almost got
sick at the sight of what was presented as "art."
Back to Rio and the
end of my visit. It wasn't too bad because Graham and Ana were coming to America
very soon, since Ana was dancing in The Nutcracker in Virginia. I
arranged for them to stay at my sisters' apartment (thanks P and D)
while they were in New York. Graham "considered" flying to London to be with his
family for Christmas, but he explained to me that their money was low. I thought
this was ridiculous, so I handed him my credit card and circled five different
travel agencies for him to call and book a flight.
Before they went to
England I arranged to have a surprise birthday party for Graham. Ana knew
nothing about it. First I brought them to a Brazilian restaurant for dinner and
then we walked along Fifth Avenue, looking at the beautiful Christmas displays
in the windows of world famous department stores. The party was held at P
and D's apartment. Since Graham and Ana were staying there, I let him use
the key he had to open the door. SURPRISE! Then Damian asked me to follow him
outside and when I went back into the apartment again, SURPRISE! It was also my
birthday, and they surprised me. Once again I saw that familiar look, which was
beyond joy, on Graham's face.
Then they were off to England for a
wonderful visit with his family.
Before I knew it they were back in New
York and then back on their way to Rio. Once again Graham and I were on opposite
sides of the equator. But we were both busy. Graham formed his own corporation
in which he acted as Ana's agent (no better product to sell) and found her guest
performances all over South America. He was also making progress with a
Brazilian production of the Crystal Palace. In addition to this was the
book about Ana that he was putting together, and many other projects. I was
improving my position at Merrill Lynch, and would soon be ready to begin the
partnership with Graham.
However, I sensed that the bureaucracy and
corruption of the Brazilian government were taking their toll on Graham as he
did whatever he could to come back here as soon as possible. He got his chance
when he arranged for Ana to perform with a Brazilian dance company in New York
in the coming Spring.
So here they were again. This time in a hotel in
the East 20's. Ana was fabulous in the performances (it was the first time I saw
her perform live on stage) and Graham was a lifesaver behind the stage as he
translated Portuguese to the American stage crew. I particularly remember one
instance when Graham called me from the hotel. I don't recall the exact details
but he needed some advice on a certain problem. I rattled off five different
solutions within three seconds. I was answered by a long pause, then a sigh of
relief, then a statement about how wonderful it was to deal with a rational
mind. This is something I could never forget.
After the performances
were finished, Ana had some appointments in Rio but Graham stayed another week
in New York. I was very happy because this allowed me to show him one of my
proudest achievements, the co-op apartment I was going to buy. He was very
impressed with the apartment, the price, the location and the building. We spoke
about the key selling points, where the bookshelves would be built and other
things. These were the moments I enjoyed most: Graham and I using our minds,
solving problems -- being productive. I began to feel that the business world
would soon be our domain to conquer, and the dollars would start rolling in.
(The main reason I felt this was true was because Graham and I were very
efficient working together. It was an excellent division of labor. He was an
expert in some fields as I was in others. And there was a complete trust between
us. Also, he had come a long way ideologically, as he accepted the most
important principles of Objectivism. A far road to travel since he had first
read Atlas Shrugged.)
The last day Graham spent in New York was
very special. My whole family was getting together for an Easter Sunday meal at
my sister Theresa's apartment in the Bronx. Finally Graham was going to meet all
the other members of the family whom he hadn't already met. Again, it was a huge
success. Then it was off to Grand Central Station, and the bus to JFK airport.
We departed at the bus stop and I noticed the expression on Graham's face. This
time it was not one of elation, but instead a calm, reserved look that promised
to be happy in the future.
So Graham would soon be in Brazil, again on
the other side of the equator.
The next few months were by far the
happiest period of my life. Indirectly, through Graham, I had finally met a
young woman who gave me the affection, pleasure and satisfaction that I had
always hoped to find. I was also moving to my new apartment and fulfilling the
American dream at age 26. (It used to be the American dream to own your own
house, but in New York in the 1980's, that dream has been compressed into owning
your own apartment.)
Once again Graham and I were reduced to writing
letters and speaking on the phone. We had considered the idea of starting an
import/export business many times, but this time we were putting more thought
into it. The summer was rolling along and I was floating on a cloud of
happiness. Then came August. My phone bill was astronomical from calling Graham
so often regarding different business projects, so I decided to honor their
second wedding anniversary by sending a special card in the mail and a message
via his telex. I asked my mother to call, as she had always enjoyed his company.
The following week I wrote him a letter filling him in on my current state of
activities, as I had taken a second job to meet my increased living expenses.
Then came the morning of August 13. It was a Saturday and I was
preparing to leave for my first ballet class in weeks. I received a phone call
from Ana in Rio. I was surprised to hear her call, and I greeted her joyfully.
There was a pause and then she went on to explain to me something about Graham
being taken in by a wave on the beach in Rio, more than 24 hours ago. Of course
this was unbelievable. How can somebody be on the beach and all of a sudden be
swallowed by a wave? But through her crying and broken English, the message was
still clear: Graham was missing.
So what should I do? One of my top
values is thousands of miles away, missing at sea, and here I am in New York
with two jobs. I called Ana twice a day for a week to see how she was. I wanted
to hear news, any news, good or bad. No news came. The only news I received from
Rio was a letter Graham had written me the day before he disappeared. The letter
was printed on his own company's stationery. It also contained some of his
business cards and there was one business card with my name on it. He was
writing to give me the latest status on the projects we were working on and also
to tell me how happy he was.
Once, a couple of days after Ana called me,
when I had slept only a few interrupted hours a night, I had a dream that Graham
and I were working on a particular task. I was excited to be working with him
again and I woke up happier than ever before. I rushed to get dressed that
morning, then reality set in: I realized it was only a dream. If I had hit the
pavement after falling off the Empire State Building, the impact would not have
been greater than the felling I had just experienced.
While not hearing
any news from Rio, I was hearing plenty of stories here in New York. Such
stories were about the possibility of tribal pagans capturing Graham because he
was an "outsider" or about him being a political prisoner. I even heard the
possible suggestions of his running away or committing suicide. Before brushing
all of the above aside as pure lunacy, I had to go there and see with my own
eyes whatever evidence I could gather. So after eleven days of hearing no news
and weighing the options of what action to take, I decided to go to Rio.
Whatever the final outcome, I had to see it form myself. I remember while my
brother Peter (thanks Peter) was driving me to JFK, I had the feeling that I was
walking the plank, blindfolded, hands tied behind back, not knowing what was
before me. But I had to do it -- for Graham.
Ana met me at the airport
with Francisco Faria. It was the middle of the winter in Rio and the middle of
the summer in New York, and there was very little difference in the weather. Ana
had just started going back to rehearsals the day before, so we dropped her off
at the Municipal Theatre. Francisco drove me to Ana's apartment, where I saw her
parents, Dr. Ernani and Maria Dulce. As I put my luggage down in Graham's den, I
stopped. There, sitting all by itself on his library, surrounded only by his
most prized possessions -- was the anniversary card I had sent. Tears streamed
down my face as I read it again.
The next thing I knew, Francisco was
driving me to the site where the event took place. Once I arrived there, I
immediately knew that only nature could have been responsible for this
occurrence. It was on the side of a mountain, where there was a narrow walkway
called the "Fisherman's Path," which stretched out over the water below. Even at
high tide, there was at least twenty feet between the ocean and the walkway.
When I arrived the tide was low and there were people actually diving off the
ledge into the water. I couldn't believe it.
Francisco explained to me
that the current was going out toward the Atlantic Ocean and he did not expect
the body to be found. On the surface I was content with this explanation. It
seemed logical. But I knew that if I went back home with this conclusion, I
would spend the rest of my life doubting that Graham was gone forever.
Most of the next few days were spent with Francisco and his wife, Bebe.
Although Graham was constantly on my mind, I was reminded of the many attractive
sites Rio has to offer. But even those beautiful women could not keep my spirits
high.
Then came Sunday night. A few of us went out to eat at one of
those all-the-food-you-can-eat places. I ate non-stop for about one hour. Then
we went back to Ana's place at around midnight. Ana was in her bedroom with
Maria Dulce and her aunt, Marguerite. I entered with Dr. Ernani, Naninho and
Marcia. I told Ana that I was so full, I would not eat for the rest of my visit.
She laughed. Then the telephone rang. We all froze. The next several hours
seemed to drag into eternity. Whatever pain I had experienced in my life before
had been nothing compared to the upcoming events.
To add frustration to
pain, the English language disappeared. My head was already spinning from
hearing Portuguese constantly spoken since my arrival. I didn't know the
details, but I knew what the person on the other end of that phone was saying. I
could decipher Ana telling the man something about the red sneakers that Graham
was wearing. (They were red Nike hightops, which Graham was the only person
anyone ever saw wear.)
Then Dr. Ernani spoke to the man on the phone, as
Ana was shaking. Once again, everything was spoken in Portuguese. I didn't know
what they were saying, but I knew that I would be going somewhere soon.
Then we were in the car. It was Dr. Ernani, Naninho, Marcia's father (a
lawyer) and me. We drove over the bridge to the city of Niteroi. It is a dark,
dingy, dreary and ominous city. Quite the opposite of the splendor and
magnificence of Rio de Janeiro. Upon arrival there was more Portuguese as Dr.
Enrage spoke with the man behind the counter. Then he went in past the door
marked "Do Not Enter." He came out within three seconds, shaking his head,
saying not to go in. But I had traveled thousands of miles to see the truth
myself. And since there is nothing in the universe that I trust more than my own
eyes, I walked straight in without a thought about future consequences.
I knew immediately that it was Graham. But I stayed looking for at least
fifteen minutes. Because it was unbearable, I had to bear the pain of looking at
him. I don't remember how many times I circled that body but each time it was
more painful than the one before.
Naninho later told me that my face was
completely pale when I came out of the door. I wouldn't have known. All I knew
was that if someone had told me that America had been bombed out of existence,
it would not have had any affect on me at that moment. I was too absorbed in
what I had just experienced.
The only good thing I learned that night
was that Graham had a fractured skull, and therefore the death was immediate.
A few hours later we were back at Ana's apartment. We spoke a little bit
more and then I assumed the responsibility of calling Grahams' family. I tried
calling both of his sisters but neither answered. Then I called his parents'
home. His sister Carola answered the phone, but since I had met Mirella before,
I asked for her. Mirella came to the phone and I introduced myself, but it was
obvious to everyone why I was calling. I told her that I had news. I explained
that the body had been found, that I had gone to identify it, and that I was
certain it was him. She repeated out loud each sentence I told her. I apologized
for bringing such news and promised to call later, after they spoke amongst
themselves. It was fortunate that Graham's immediate family were all together
when the final news came from me. Mirella asked me if I wanted to speak with
Kenneth. I said I'd rather call later and she agreed. Then Margot, here mother,
came on the phone to thank me for calling. Then she uttered something that
sounded like, "My son is gone!" I hope never to hear a human voice sound like
that again.
The next few days were completely unbearable. I arranged to
have my flight postponed a couple of days, so I could be with Ana. But I soon
came to regret this decision because I felt that I was the one who needed help.
My only desire was to leave that city, that country, that continent, that
hemisphere, and come back home to New York. I felt that my job was done. I went
to Brazil as a complete human being. I would be leaving with a part of my soul
gone forever.
The funeral was beautiful. Although Ana's family wanted it
to be a private funeral, the whole city somehow found out and hundreds of people
arrived at the cemetery. I am sure Graham knew how important he was to me, but I
wondered if he ever really knew how special he was to the hundreds of people who
stood by solemnly, with their heads bowed as the coffin was carried past them.
I was unable to close my eyes for days. Each time I attempted it, all I
would see was the corpse of my best friend.
The night before I left Rio
to come back home, Marie Dulce cooked a special meal for me. (Lasagna, my
favorite, of course.) This was one of the most pleasant evenings I ever had.
Instead of being depressed, we were all speaking of the good times we had with
Graham. I remember telling them stories about how Graham and I would be working
on a project and how we would disagree over whose idea would be implemented.
Everyone would laugh because they could clearly visualize the story, including
the typical reactions of Graham, which we all knew so well. I remember thinking
to myself that this is how Graham would want to be remembered. Not by having
everyone suffer at his loss, but instead by being remembered for the happy
experiences he gave us all.
Then I was off to New York the next evening.
I was very sad to leaving Ana behind, but I was anticipating my own recovery. My
job was done. As painful as it was, the trip was a complete success. I had gone
to Brazil to be with Ana, to learn the truth about what had happened and,
hopefully, to be there when the body was discovered. I had done all this and
much more.
As always, the skyline of New York filled me with excitement
as the plane circled around and then landed in the city that never sleeps. But
for me it was still impossible to sleep. Even though I was home, it was too
early to carry on with my life. Slowly, gradually, I went into the routine of
performing my job functions, but it took a while before I began enjoying my work
again.
Throughout the whole episode of Graham's death, I have heard many
different explanations of the cause. As an Objectivist, I life by the guidance
of reason, i.e., sense perception and logic, and I hold that human beings have
free will. This means that I reject mysticism, such as the belief in God, and
the concept of fate. Therefore, such explanations as "God took him," or "It was
his time," do not explain anything to me. Graham was at that site, at that time,
by his own choice. Nothing forced him. Graham was a risk taker; that was his
nature. He lived his life close to the edge and that is how he died. He loved
the excitement of the sea. That is what brought him there on that tragic day.
Nothing else. And the wave was a natural event. But Graham was not negligent. If
he had known there would be a gigantic wave coming that would endanger his life,
he would have avoided it. There is no way he can be blamed.
One thing I
can say about Graham is that he was human. But I do not mean this in the
derogatory sense, I mean it in the noble sense. It is only human beings that are
capable of being rational, honest, independent, productive, courageous -- and
great. He strived to be the highest type of man he could. And he succeeded.
There is one particular virtue Graham possessed which stands out in my
mind. He was proud. When I first met him, I immediately sensed that we were
brothers-in-spirit. We had similar ambitions, standards and values, but there
was a huge gap between his self-esteem and mine. I think this is why he really
enjoyed my company. Graham had as much ability, endurance, and motivation as
anyone I'd met before. But his self-esteem was dreadfully low, as he often
admitted. I showed him how this is the most crucial aspect of one's life. That
the purpose of life is to attain happiness and that this can not be done unless
one has earned a deep pride in oneself. He had never heard this before. With
time and conscientious effort, Graham greatly improved his evaluation of
himself. I do not know how many people observed his dramatic increase in
confidence and efficacy, but since this is the standard by which I judge people,
it was very obvious to me.
This is what Graham learned from me. But what
have I learned from him? A lifetime's supply of knowledge, experience and
happiness. Graham showed me that there is a world beyond the United States. It
is with him that I went to England and Brazil. He also showed me many new ways
to continually improve myself. His criticisms were very constructive and he
always made it clear that he was there to help. There was never a trace of
mockery or malevolence when he would make a suggestion. This is such a rare
quality among people that I almost forgot that it exists in his absence. Graham
taught me to always strive for the highest attainable values, whether it was by
finding a more demanding job with a much higher income, or by improving my
standard of living by finding a better apartment in which to live.
Graham had as wide a variety of interests as anyone I've ever known. He
could comfortably speak about the most complex issues of art, philosophy, or
business. And although he was very intelligent, he never found it degrading to
perform manual labor. He was a true builder. Within this context, Graham is the
artist, the blacksmith, the ploughman and the philosopher who will always hold a
high place in my life and brought me closer to the heart. But in addition to all
that, Graham was a friend. It is Aristotle who once said that a friend is
another self. This could very explain why I enjoyed Graham's existence so much.
In his being, I had a chance to witness the very qualities which I admire in
myself. And when I sometimes lapsed in my own standards, I would notice his
integrity and then make an effort to rise up to that level again. This is why
Graham was an irreplaceable value.
These past six months have surely
been difficult for me. And although there will always be a part of me remaining
in that cemetery in Rio de Janeiro, there is a larger part of Graham which will
remain with me forever. It is for these reasons that my confidence in myself has
risen to its highest level. I can probably say that until now I have never
really been tested. And coping with the death of a loved one is something I had
never done before. But death is a fact of life, and I must continue on. And I
will. Since last August I have had many different opportunities to prove to
myself that I could continue on my road to success. Such opportunities to prove
to myself that I could continue on my road to success. Such opportunities have
resulted in my being promoted to Night Shift Manager at Merrill Lynch, winning
and important Sales Championship contest and being the top student in a real
estate sales course. These are only the most recent achievements, but with
Graham's legacy, I have very high expectations for more in the future.
Sometimes I stop and ask myself the question: If Graham were alive
today, would he be proud of me? When I ask this question, the only image I see
is that very familiar expression of joy on his face. I know that this is enough
to carry me past any obstacles I might face for the rest of my life.
...
Closer to the Heart
Robert Begley, February, 1989
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Closer To The Heart
"And the men
who hold high places
Must be the ones who start
To mould a new reality
Closer to the Heart
The Blacksmith and the Artist
Reflect it in
their art
They forge their creativity
Closer to the Heart
Philosophers and Ploughmen
Each must know his part
To sow a new
mentality
Closer to the Heart
You can be the captain
I will draw
the chart
Sailing into destiny
Closer to the Heart"
-- Peart, Talbot
Identity
Staring at the skyline
For the very last time.
Certain of the values
He will leave behind.
Denied opportunity
In the land of opportunity.
Condemned by
virtue of race
To exist in another place
Didn't want a handout
Didn't want a handcuff
Just wanted to earn his keep
And keep a
little more than enough
Born in the old world
Liberated in the new
world
Exiled to the third world
Seeing yet another flag unfurled.
Feeling the subway rumble
Down beneath his feet.
He thinks about
the city
And it's pulsating beat.
Hearing a plane soar
Up above
his head.
Soon to be on one
To a place he will dread.
On to this
new life
Mired in corruption.
Where achievement is looted
And
innovators booted.
Flying over the city
He always loved so much.
Head pressed to the window
Passport drops from his clutch.